| | SLO | ENG | Cookies and privacy

Bigger font | Smaller font

Show document Help

Title:Virtue, Knowledge, and Good Life – Insights from Buddhism : doctoral dissertation
Authors:ID Sarkar, Joyitri (Author)
ID Klampfer, Friderik (Mentor) More about this mentor... New window
Files:.pdf DOK_Sarkar_Joyitri_2026.pdf (1,76 MB)
MD5: 38A6596CE41ACCDFE53EFE0287899784
 
Language:English
Work type:Doctoral dissertation
Typology:2.08 - Doctoral Dissertation
Organization:FF - Faculty of Arts
Abstract:The central research question explored in this thesis is: What does it mean, and what does it take to live a good life? More precisely, the thesis examines the relationship between knowledge and virtues, concentrating on the meeting point of Buddhist and Western virtue ethics. One of the age-old and most hotly contested philosophical topics is what constitutes a good life. The rich Buddhist tradition has been ignored and/or misinterpreted in the West. At the same time, Western virtue ethics, with its origins in Ancient Greece and its first climax in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, has significantly impacted the history of Western philosophy. This thesis will examine Buddhist philosophy from a new perspective, drawing on my knowledge of Buddhist philosophical and religious ideas and practices and my experience with Indian culture. The examination will primarily concentrate on the characteristics of the Buddhist counterparts of the Aristotelian notions of virtue, practical knowledge, happiness, and the good life, as well as the relationships among them. The core ideas of ancient Greek and modern virtue ethics are strikingly similar to the Buddhist notions of Nirvāṇa, enlightenment, the Middle Path, and the Eightfold Path. These ideas are the foundation of the Buddhist intellectual heritage. The thesis aims to bridge the apparent divide between the two cultures or civilisations and show that, beyond some indisputable differences, they share many features that provide a shared intellectual basis for what is now commonly known as the global ethic, rather than to draw a sharp boundary between these two traditions. Philosophical traditions have debated the idea of the 'good life' for a long time, providing a variety of viewpoints on what makes for a purposeful and happy life. Fundamentally, living a good life is frequently defined as achieving happiness, health, and a life that aligns with one's moral principles and ideals. It is influenced by moral conduct, deep connections, the search for knowledge, as well as by happiness and inner fulfilment. Buddhism defines the 'Good Life' as a peaceful existence based on moral behaviour, knowledge, and mental discipline, ultimately resulting in enlightenment (Nirvāṇa) and the end of suffering. The reconstructed ideal of the Bodhisattva promises to offer a solution to the difficulties of leading a moral life in the modern world. This thesis offers a comprehensive explanation of human flourishing that integrates ideas from modern moral philosophy, Aristotelian virtue theory, and Buddhist ethics. It makes the case that the best way to understand the ideal life is as a dynamic interaction between virtue, knowledge, and compassion, underpinned by relational responsibility and attentive awareness. The project overcomes the tendency of previous accounts to see thriving as either exclusively ascetic (as in specific readings of Buddhism) or primarily intellectual (as in some interpretations of Aristotle) by establishing ethical excellence in both cultivated compassion and rational deliberation In contrast to earlier attempts, the proposed framework (1) expands virtue ethics by incorporating compassion, global responsibility, and attentional discipline at its core; (2) interprets Buddhist mindfulness and the Bodhisattva ideal as moral as well as contemplative practices, elucidating their ethical depth beyond "wellness" discourses; and (3) offers a cross-cultural vocabulary for connecting character formation, epistemic clarity, and altruistic concern. This account emphasizes the interdependence of self-cultivation, understanding, and relational care, providing a richer and more practically relevant guide for living well in pluralistic, interconnected societies than solutions that favor a single tradition or reduce ethics to rules or consequences.
Keywords:Buddhist Nirvāṇa, Bodhisattva, good life, virtues, mindfulness, friendship, non-attachment, weell-being, llourishing, happiness
Place of publishing:Maribor
Place of performance:Maribor
Publisher:J. Sarkar
Year of publishing:2026
Number of pages:1 spletni vir (1 datoteka PDF (202 str.))
PID:20.500.12556/DKUM-95832 New window
UDC:17:24(043.3)
COBISS.SI-ID:286100227 New window
Publication date in DKUM:27.07.2026
Views:164
Downloads:19
Metadata:XML DC-XML DC-RDF
Categories:FF
:
Copy citation
  
Average score:(0 votes)
Your score:Voting is allowed only for logged in users.
Share:Bookmark and Share



Hover the mouse pointer over a document title to show the abstract or click on the title to get all document metadata.

Licences

License:CC BY-NC-ND 4.0, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International
Link:http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Description:The most restrictive Creative Commons license. This only allows people to download and share the work for no commercial gain and for no other purposes.
Licensing start date:08.07.2026

Secondary language

Language:Slovenian
Title:Vrlina, vednost in dobro življenje – uvidi iz budizma
Abstract:Osrednje raziskovalno vprašanje, na katero iščemo odgovor v pričujoči tezi, se glasi: Kaj pomeni živeti dobro življenje? Natančneje, v tezi je osrednja pozornost namenjena vlogi, ki jo v dobrem življenju igrajo modrost in vrline. Če smo še nekoliko natančnejši, v ospredju našega zanimanja je odnos med vednostjo in vrlinami, kot sta ga tematizirali budistična misel in zahodna etika vrlin. Budistična tradicija je bila na Zahodu večinoma prezrta ali pa napačno razumljena. Po drugi strani pa je zahodna etika vrlin, ki izvira iz starogrške misli in je svoj prvi vrhunec dosegla v Aristotelovi Nikomahovi etiki, močno zaznamovala zgodovino zahodne filozofije. V pričujoči tezi se budistične misli lotevam iz nekoliko drugačnega zornega kota, naslanjajoč se na svoje poznavanje budističnih filozofskih in verskih idej ter praks, pa tudi na osebne izkušnje z indijsko kulturo. Analiza se osredotoča predvsem na značilnosti budističnih ustreznic aristotelovskim pojmom vrline, praktičnega znanja, sreče in dobrega življenja ter njihove medsebojne odnose. Temeljne ideje starogrške in sodobne etike vrline so presenetljivo podobne budističnim pojmom nirvāṇa, razsvetljenja, Srednje poti in Osemčlene poti. Ti koncepti so temelj budistične intelektualne dediščine. V disertaciji poskušamo premostiti navidezni razkorak med obema kulturama oziroma civilizacijama ter pokazati, da so med njima številne podobnosti, ki bi lahko priskrbele skupno intelektualno osnovo za to, kar danes imenujejo svetovna etika — namesto da bi ti dve intelektualni tradiciji ostro razmejevali, kot se je rado dogajalo v preteklosti. Filozofske tradicije že dolgo razpravljajo o ideji »dobrega življenja«, pri čemer ponujajo različne poglede na to, kaj tvori smiselno in srečno življenje. V svojem bistvu je dobro življenje pogosto opredeljeno kot doseganje sreče, zdravja in življenja, ki se ujema z našimi moralnimi načeli in ideali. Na to vplivajo moralno ravnanje, globoke povezave z drugimi, iskanje znanja ter občutka sreče in notranje izpolnitve. Budizem opredeljuje dobro življenje kot mirno bivanje, utemeljeno na moralnem vedenju, znanju in duševni disciplini, ki nazadnje vodi v razsvetljenje (nirvāṇa) in konec trpljenja. V idealu bodhisattve se skrivajo nekatere zanimive rešitve za izzive moralnega življenja. Pričujoča teza ponuja celovito pojmovanje človeškega razcveta, ki plodno povezuje ideje sodobne moralne filozofije, Aristotelove teorije vrline in budistične etike. Zagovarja stališče, da je idealno življenje najbolje razumeti kot dinamično prepletanje vrline, znanja in sočutja, ki temelji na odnosni odgovornosti in zavedanju. Projekt postavlja etično odličnost v negovano sočutje in razumno presojo in na ta način presega omejitve prejšnjih pristopov, ki so človeško uspevanje, blagostanje oz. razcvet razumeli bodisi izključno asketsko (kot v nekaterih interpretacijah budizma) bodisi predvsem intelektualno (kot v določenih interpretacijah Aristotela). V nasprotju s prejšnjimi poskusi predlagani okvir: (1) razširja etiko vrline z vključevanjem sočutja, globalne odgovornosti in discipline pozornosti kot njenega jedra; (2) razlaga budistično čuječnost in ideal bodhisattve kot moralno in kontemplativno prakso ter osvetljuje njuno etično globino onkraj diskurzov o »dobrem počutju«; in (3) ponuja medkulturni besednjak za povezovanje oblikovanja značaja, spoznavne jasnosti in altruistične skrbi. Predlagani pristop poudarja medsebojno povezanost samokultivacije, razumevanja in skrbnih odnosov ter ponuja bogatejši in praktično bolj uporaben vodnik za dobro življenje v pluralističnih, medsebojno povezanih družbah — v primerjavi z rešitvami, ki dajejo prednost eni sami tradiciji ali zreducirajo etiko na rigidna pravila ali preračunavanje posledic.
Keywords:budistična nirvana, razsvetljeno bitje, dobro življenje, vrline, čuječnost, prijateljstvo, ne-navezanost, dobrobit, razcvet, sreča


Comments

Leave comment

You must log in to leave a comment.

Comments (0)
0 - 0 / 0
 
There are no comments!

Back
Logos of partners University of Maribor University of Ljubljana University of Primorska University of Nova Gorica